The 5th Dimension would cover a total of six Laura Nyro songs and have big hits between 1968 and 1970 as “Wedding Bell Blues” hit #1, “Stoned Soul Picnic” reached #3, “Sweet Blindness” #13, , “Blowing Away” #21 and “Save the Country” #27.
I do recall a high school friend had the 1970 album Stoney End by Barbra Streisand and it would have been around 1976 or so that I read the liner notes (because that’s what one might do in ancient times) and saw her name. Not that the name meant anything to me at the time but I had also seen her name as the songwriter for “Eli’s Coming” on the hit song by Three Dog Night from 1969. Just a point of personal trivia, our now 12 year old Quaker Parrot is named Eli, after the song of course.
It wasn’t until 1994 when I really discovered Laura Nyro. We are coming up on the 30th anniversary of the passing of my father and father-in-law during the same week in February of that year. At the end of the month we were blessed with our second daughter. So during this time there was some introspection going on. A song I had always liked was the Blood, Sweat & Tears version of “And When I Die”.
And when I die and when I’m gone
There’ll be one child born
In this world, carry on, to carry on
Well I could not have found a more appropriate song for the circumstances. Thinking about the lyrics, the words, led me to take a closer look at Laura Nyro and her writing. I was able to find a brief pause in what was otherwise a chaotic time and much more since from her songs. Her voice was full of emotion and her range was very impressive. I was quite sad when I learned of her passing just three years later in April of 1997.
Laura was only 17 years old when she wrote “And When I Die” and it was her very first complete song. There was clearly an old soul already full of wisdom to be able to write such a song, at any age. It is the only one of her 43 songs that have been covered that she did not originally record herself. Her first single that she recorded and released at age 18 is “Wedding Bell Blues”, it is on her debut album More Than a New Discovery (1967).
We need to remember how exceptional it was for a young woman to release an album of her own songs. Certainly there is what I would call a latent appreciation out there for Laura. I won’t refer to her as an ‘unknown’ but during her time she did not sell a lot of albums nor did she chart any singles. As noted there were some significant covers of her songs but in truth if you are not the singer of the song, people don’t pay a lot of attention to the songwriter.
Let me give some examples of some of the greatest female singer/songwriters in history. Billie Holiday was 18 when her first single was released but for any song she had written/co-written it would be in her early 30’s for her first album. The trail blazing Carole King released her first single in 1958 at age 17, focused on songwriting her first album was released when she was 28. In the 1960’s Dolly Parton had written singles released by other artists at age 19 and her first album was at age 20. Nina Simone was in her mid twenties for her own songs to appear on her albums, as was Peggy Lee. Joni Mitchell wrote all her own songs and was in her mid 20’s for her first releases. Aretha Franklin was not as prolific a songwriter but did write a couple of her top ten hits such as “Think”(1968), again she was in her twenties. These are all legendary artists but also exceedingly rare.
Later would come names such as Kate Bush, who at age 19 in 1978 was the first female ever in the UK to have a #1 self written song. Then we would have Adel and Taylor Swift for example with self written releases before age 20. I am perhaps belaboring the point but I just want get across the scarcity of such a person as Laura Nyro.
Here is a song for which I cannot find a cover version, why I have no idea.
The album Angel in the Dark was released in 2001, four years after her passing. The album also contains some incredible cover versions of songs that were of influence to her such as “Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow” and “Let It Be Me“. While her early work gets the most attention I think songs like these prove her skills as a singer/songwriter did not fade.