These two songs placed #1 on the *Best Selling Soul Singles (R&B) weekly charts and stood out for me (on the #2’s list) because I bet I’m not alone in still listening to them: “Mr. Big Stuff” by Jean Knight and “Spanish Harlem” by Aretha Franklin, both from 1971.
“Spanish Harlem” was a cover of Ben E King’s original hit song, and Aretha peaked at #2 with her version and was #49 at year-end on Billboard’s Hot 100. Her song was stopped by “Go Away Little Girl” from Donny Osmond, (you just can’t make this stuff up!).
“Mr. Big Stuff” finished the year (1971) at #1 on the Best Selling Soul Singles (R&B) year-end charts but peaked at #2 on Billboard’s Hot 100 weekly charts and ended the year at #18. It was held back by the Bee Gees first American #1 song “How Can You Mend a Broken Heart”.
“Mr. Big Stuff” was released by Stax Records and written by Joseph Broussard, Carrol Washington and Tony Clarke. There are only 23 versions of this song, perhaps because it’s just too distinctive to attempt. However enough of the song was used by Heavy D. & The Boyz (1986) to be classified as a ‘Cover’ as it used too much of the song to be called a ‘Sample’. The video has a long lead in but it’s pretty entertaining.
“Spanish Harlem” was written by Jerry Leiber and Phil Spector. Aretha had changed the “red rose” lyrics to “There’s a rose in Black ‘n Spanish Harlem. A rose in Black ‘n Spanish Harlem.” There were over twenty versions between the original and Aretha’s and the song now has 196 recordings, which includes many dozen’s of instrumentals.
Cliff Richard covered this song in 1962 and also recorded it German “Das Ist Die Frage Aller Fragen”.
*From August 23, 1969, the Hot Rhythm & Blues Singles chart was renamed to Best Selling Soul Singles. It was changed to Hot Black Singles in late June of 1982. Typically we say R&B charts and I think most people understand the reference as there have been a dozen changes over the years. The next name was Hot R&B Singles, then Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Singles & Tracks and now it’s Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs.
Personally I think if we have the Hot 100, why they did not go with the Hip 100 is a mystery to me. Yes I know the think-tanks will be lining up to ask my advice – not.
More to read about at Music Mondays by Leon.