Boogie Woogie

Meade Lux Lewis with his original composition first recorded in 1927 “Honky Tonk Train Blues”

Anderson Meade Lewis was known as Meade Lux Lewis (1905-1964). While he did not invent Boogie Woogie, he is a good place to start the conversation. Meade was from Chicago which in the 1920s was becoming a leading center for Boogie Woogie music.

But let’s not get ahead of ourselves. Just what is Boogie Woogie anyway?

As I often say when trying to explain anything to anyone (who is not my wife), “I am no expert”. Surprisingly she is still not convinced, where was I? Yes, a definition.

Boogie Woogie Beginnings

It’s a bit hard to define precisely from what I have read over the years. Carnegie Hall played a very important part in the genre so I looked to their website for a definition. I can’t find a better one, and my reading and notes just won’t gel for me so here it is from Carnegie.

Boogie-woogie, primarily a piano-based style, is one of the most rhythmically intense forms of blues music. Its evolution began in the late 1800s among pianists in the rough-and-tumble city taverns and rural juke joints, and it spread to the traveling vaudeville shows. It was a feature in the barrelhouses in the logging, sawmill, turpentine, levee, and railroad camps throughout the South. In Texas the piano style was known as “fast western.” The basic boogie-woogie rhythm, an outgrowth of ragtime and rural blues, is said to have been inspired by the rhythmic clacking of steam locomotives throughout the Deep South”.

We know a few things more specifically, the suggestion is the origins may be from Piney Woods, Texas. It was there in the 1870s that Black piano players seemed to have developed the style while playing at the nearby camps mentioned in the definition. It’s typified by the left hand holding a bass pattern (a walking bass line), and the right hand playing a counter pattern with more variety. You may have heard the term “Left Hand of/like God”1.

Some reading I did suggests it and the sort of low-level Barrelhouse (cheap saloons) music is one and the same. It’s true in the early days there were similarities and many played in a hybrid of Barrelhouse/Ragtime/Boogie Woogie with the latter evolving far beyond, having a distinctive style.

This sound gave a great dance beat and small buildings were erected at these camps and a piano was put in place for the workers to let off some steam. The piano players began to travel from camp to camp and more and more people, both blacks and whites were learning the style. Oh, and that Meade Lux Lewis song “Honky Tonk Train Blues” was a real thing, trains with pianos and no seats, just a dance floor. By the early 1900’s the music was now ubiquitous throughout the South and players shared stages with the other Blues players of the day.

Well, it turns out you just can’t keep a good thing to yourself and that right hand was adding more melodies, riffs, licks, and any number of fancy things (technical term). Like other forms of The Blues, it was transported North during the Great Migration. St. Louis, Detroit, and Chicago in particular were really boogie-woogie-ing. We had stuff going “Down in New Orleans”2 as well.

Now, a hundred things were going on with Boogie Woogie, but I am writing a blog post here so I am compressing things a lot. For example, apart from as mentioned above, there is an intersection here with Stride Jazz. And don’t get me started on the guitar players like Blind Lemon Jefferson and Big Bill Broonzy who were exposed to it and incorporated this style.

“Pine Top’s Boogie Woogie” by (Clarence) Pinetop Smith. You could not have a better instructional audio. Among other things, he tells people to “mess around” which is a dance move. That’s what Boogie Woogie was all about.

Early Names

I could toss you dozens of names from Romeo Nelson to Cripple Clarence and Roosevelt Sykes but let’s follow one particular path. Practitioners such as the Composer George Washington Thomas (“The New Orleans Hop Scop Blues“) and his brother Hersal, brought it to Chicago. This is where pioneer Jimmy Yancy would come into the picture and influence Meade Lux Lewis and his childhood friend Albert Ammons. A third player, Pinetop Smith who had played in Ma Rainey’s band came to Chicago on the advice of another very important early boogie-woogie-style piano player known as Cow Cow Davenport. Smith’s “Pinetop’s Blues” and “Pinetops Boogie Woogie” from 1928 are genre standards. As it happens Meade and Albert would also learn from Pinetop and at one point they were rooming together in Chicago.

The Depression arrived and the dollars for buying records were few and Boogie Woogie piano was rarely recorded and mostly relegated to shows in the South. The whole live entertainment industry was suffering along with almost everyone else. So for Meade and other musicians, there were no venues in Chicago where he could get a gig. That would change in 1938 when John Hammond found him washing cars for a living and gave him an invitation.

How do you get to Carnegie Hall?

Sometime back I did a guest piece for Turntable Talk 11 where I wrote about the important event called the From Spirituals to Swing concerts, the first (one at least) was a tribute to the late Bessie Smith and held at Carnegie Hall on December 23, 1938, and a second show a year later on December 24, 1939. As part of many legendary leaders in music, that first event featured Count Basie, and Sister Rosetta Tharpe, and the first concert was the setting for a debut performance of some of the recently deceased Robert Johnson’s songs. The second show it was the Benny Goodman Sextet and returning was Count Basie and this time with vocalist Helen Humes.

The event was organized by John Hammond who I have spoken about many times and his importance to American music cannot be understated. When he found Meade in Chicago he asked him to play this gig at Carnegie Hall. Among the many Blues, Big Band and Gospel artists singing/playing, were his friends Albert Ammons and Pinetop Smith. Along with Big Joe Turner and Pete Johnson, over the two shows they would perform Boogie Woogie Piano for the first time before a New York audience. This led to appearances at many New York venues including the swanky Café Society nightclub, which opened in 1939.

The Proliferation

The Andrew Sisters “Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy”

Soon Boogie Woogie, sometimes more in name than style was showing up everywhere. Yes, I do mean everywhere. And why not, the music was a lot of fun. From The Andrew Sisters “Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy” (1941) to Judy Garland and Novelty Songs and it had already found its way into Texas Swing. We even had Country and Western Music star Tennessee Ernie Ford’s “Shotgun Boogie”. It was in Big Band music, Tommy Dorsey, etc., and in a small way, other forms of Jazz Music (the purists hated it). You had Cab Calloway using it in his act to any number of songs with some kind of “Boogie” and or “Woogie” in it or in the title. And movies, of course.

Sugar Chile Robinson was born in 1938 and is still with us today at age 85.

On the downside you had Meade Lux Lewis refused membership into ASCAP, the publishing organization that would have allowed him to collect royalties from his song that I started the post with “Honky Tonk Train Blues”. It now has nearly 100 versions. After a bit of a battle he was allowed to join ASCAP in 1942. Unfortunately this was after Bob Crosby and His Orchestra had sold many records with his “Honky Tonk Train Blues” in 1939 and “Yancy Blues” in 1938.

Until it was reversed after he was exposed by John Hammond, Decca Executive Jack Kapp copyrighted the words “Boogie Woogie” in an effort to control (collect royalties) from all the so-named songs including the pioneering Smith’s “Pinetops Boogie Woogie”, which was the first time the words were used in a recorded song title.

The amazing Martha Davis. “Martha’s Boogie”. That’s her husband Calvin Ponder on Bass.

As with any good thing, the high never lasts. Remember that Swifties. There was a downturn and of course, there had been and still are the detractors as well. Jelly Roll Morton, said to be an early proponent had a clause in his contract stating he could not be asked to perform a Boogie Woogie song. Others would call it rudimentary music and lacking in any artistic merit.

Still, the style now included tunes from the guitar, ensembles, and whole orchestras. As for the piano players some more than others were adept at many styles but if Boogie Woogie was your forte you needed to find an audience.

Despite the lack of interest in most of the US, as I alluded to earlier some people in New Orleans were feeling differently. So were many Europeans. You may have heard about some of that, and this whole Rock and Roll thing, something familiar there as well.

It sounds like we need a Part 2. This has been a long one so we will give it a few days before I write/post it. In the meantime, over the next while, I will just send out a couple clips of some of the great names in Boogie Woogie. Thanks for reading as always.

  1. Further reading: The Story of Boogie-Woogie: A Left Hand Like God by Peter J. Silvester ↩︎
  2. That’s a Dr. John song reference ↩︎

Robert Johnson

21641566_web1_200526-CDT-johnson-photographs-1_1

These are the only three known photographs of Robert Johnson, all obtained from family members, some after a 13 year legal battle. Now, even if you know nothing about the Delta Blues you have likely heard of Robert Johnson. Today I will give a brief synopsis on the Man, the Myth and the Music.

The Man

Robert Johnson (May 8, 1911, Hazlehurst, Mississippi – August 16, 1938). Singer-songwriter, guitarist and the quintessential itinerant musician. He travelled mainly in the state of Mississippi, Memphis, Tennessee and Helena, Arkansas areas. Often identified incorrectly as the first “Bluesman” however there is little doubt as to his mastery of the guitar and his influence is as legendary as his own brief life story.

I made reference to him in my two prior ‘Delta Blues’ posts: on Charlie Patton and Johnson I could not find any reference that they had met and for Son House, we know their paths surely crossed several times. It is his (House) account among just a few others that confirms the stories of how Johnson went from at best, a mediocre player to a great one in a span of just a couple years. Although that story, even from House himself has a few different acounts. But if you read the piece I did on Son House, he effectively did the same thing. So did Big Bill Broonzy, later a mentor to Muddy Waters in Chicago. Maybe not quite as good as Johnson, agreed, but the point is what was done was perhaps not as exceptional as it’s made out to be.

We know that for much of the period he went away it was to stay with and be taught by Ike Zimmerman who at that time was living in Beauregard, Mississippi with his family. According to accounts by Zimmerman’s family, Ike liked to practice in the Cemetery at night, perhaps so as not to bother people. He took Robert Johnson there for some of his lessons, just beyond the local ‘crossroads’. People would often gather outdoors to hear him play.

Johnson had several things that led to his greatness, natural talent, a willingness to work hard at his craft, a great music memory and the ability to create the right songs for the right moment. Johnson’s ability went beyond the Blues, when he played he would go through an impressive repertoire of the popular songs of the day.

He did travel up to Chicago at least once with Johnny Shines and played a bit with Henry Townsend, David ‘Honeyboy” Edwards and via that relationship it is said that Robert Lockwood Jr may have been the only guitar player to have been tutored by Johnson.

The Myth

You may have heard of the story of the man who sold his soul to the devil for mastery over the guitar, that myth is about Robert Johnson. And myth it is. In fact Blues music was referred to as “The Devils Music” by Church goers in the South. More than one bluesman was labelled as “the devil”, Ike Zimmerman and Tommy Johnson (no relation) are two such that had an association with Robert Johnson.

There are also various accounts of how he died, and what he died of, but we know it was at the age of 27. A likely theory to me is that he was poisoned by tainted whisky provided by a jealous husband due to a possible encounter of some type with his wife. Johnson had been playing nearby for several days and was staying at a Plantation. This is where he had rather eventfully and painfully passed away on August 16 of 1938. This is (in part) the account from David Honeyboy Edwards and seems plausible to me. Yet many researchers have slightly different stories.

I’m just going by memory here but I don’t believe his death certificate was uncovered until the late 60’s, early 70’s, and apparently there was no Doctor involved and the Plantation owner listed his cause of death as syphilis. Regardless, he lived a life that was hard on his body and whether it was helped along or not he died too young.

After he died, news of course travelled slowly in those days and, not knowing he was dead, he was added to a concert in New York, which I will talk about later. The event organizer John Hammond had sent people to retrieve Johnson, instead bringing back news of his passing. This also helped to fuel some of the mystery about Johnson. As to what degree I cannot say but there is some revisionist history going on in relation to Robert Johnson.

The Music

“Ramblin’ on My Mind”

His two recording sessions occurred in San Antonio and Dallas. The accounting of these sessions conducted by music engineer Don Law and particularly the first session at the Gunter Hotel, November 23 to the 27th in 1936 has been played out in songs, books, movies and tv shows. The second session was June 19 and 20, 1937, in Dallas. He recorded 30 songs in total, 29 were released over three years; 1937, 38 & 39 and the last not until 1961.

Here is one of the songs he wrote which tells the story of a man at critical time in his life and it helped to feed the mythology of selling his soul to the devil (which is never actually referenced in this nor any of his songs).

“Cross Road Blues” by Robert Johnson (Nov. 27th 1936). Covered about 135 times to date.

Eric Clapton and The Powerhouse, from a compilation album What’s Shakin’ (June 1966). This features Steve Winwood on vocals. The group only recorded four songs, this is one of three to be released. The feature group on the album was the Lovin’ Spoonful but also included; The Paul Butterfield Blues Band, Al Kooper and Tom Rush.

A much lauded song is Johnson’s version of “Sweet Home Chicago” (if you listen to all the other versions) it is only marginally different than the song(s) it came from, given again some of his guitar playing is what set’s it apart. Prior to “Sweet Home Chicago” it was known most popularly as “Kokomo Blues”. It was first recorded as “Kokola Blues” (more of misprint than anything) by Madlyn Davis and Her Hot Shots, released in 1928. It was adapted before Johnson got hold of it by the noted Piedmont Bluesman Scrapper Blackwell in 1928 and then Kokomo Arnold in 1934. Prior to Johnson the song is listed as Traditional with the author unknown.

“Kokomo Blues” by Scrapper Blackwell

“Sweet Home Chicago” by Robert Johnson.

Johnson’s records were not widely sold or distributed. True, some copies were coveted by collectors, some songs were no doubt heard by musicians. Mostly limited to the above “Sweet Home Chicago”. But after he died, most never even knew it happen for months or years later. Granted not all forgot about him as I indicated above, John Hammond had heard his records. Hammond by 1938 and age 28 was well on his way to becoming one of the most important people in music of the 20th Century. Later he would spark the career’s of Billie Holiday, Aretha Franklin, Bob Dylan and Bruce Springsteen to name a few.

In 1938 on December 23, there was a concert held at Carnegie Hall called From Spirituals to Swing (A concert in the loving memory of Bessie Smith). The organizer, Mr. John Hammond came out at one point and said that one of the names on the event poster, the singer Robert Johnson had passed away. They played a couple of his songs from a record. Hammond had Big Bill Broonzy come as a “stand in” who it is said was one of the few capable at that time, played a couple of Johnsons other songs. On the recordings however the only two songs from Broonzy are his own songs. So I can’t be positive he actually did perform a Johnson song. Regardless the playing of the records added to the mystery of Robert Johnson.

This event sparked some interest in seeking out his records and most certainly John Hammond was high on him but then he was high on many of the great Blues and Jazz and later Rock artists. Truth is Johnson was relatively obscure until, as I noted in the post on Son House, the Folk revival in the early 60’s.

“I Believe I’ll Dust My Broom” as it was titled when written by Robert Johnson and recorded at the famed Gunter Hotel sessions in San Antonio, Texas on November 23, 1936. It certainly inspired Elmore James to add his own twist and cover the song “Dust My Broom” in 1951. This song was adapted from several older Blues songs.

When the Folk Revival was in progress John Hammond, still remembering Johnson, was behind the album Robert Johnson King of the Delta Blues Players in 1961 released on Columbia Records. This ignited interest in Delta Blues players and if you read my post on Son House, sparked the search that brought him back.

“Hellhound on my Tail”

My Perspective on the Legacy

We know that songs written by many of the Delta Blues singers, often contained lines and melodies from others and or older songs. Johnson certainly seized upon this opportunity better than most when he made those recordings. I know the author Elijah Wald did a great job breaking down Johnson’s songs. I don’t disagree with any assessment resulting in praise for Johnson’s skills.

Clearly many were influenced by his technique, apart from some of his contemporaries you can read that Eric Clapton, Bob Dylan, Keith Richards, Robert Plant and many more cite Johnson as an influence. But let me just say, if people are asked about a specific person that did have a positive affect on their music, they are going to have something good to say. If Robert Johnson is your “holy grail” of blues or whatever, than I think that’s great. Listen, not everyone likes The Beatles and/or The Rolling Stones, but for some those are their “holy grail”.

Let’s just single out Eric Clapton, a self professed Blues guitar player and what he has said about names that influenced him, “Robert Johnson to me is the most important blues musician who ever lived”. But he has said he learned to play listening to Big Bill Broonzy and Muddy Waters, both heavily influenced by Son House. He cites Broonzy as a great technician with “perfect rhythm”. Clapton has said more than once that his greatest influence was Muddy Waters and they formed a very close relationship, he looked up to Waters as a bit of a father figure.

If I sound like I am bashing Robert Johnson, I am not. I am however bashing the hype. I like the the story and the myth, I get a kick out of seeing it in a movie or whatever. I have learned about so many of the great early blues, folk blues, country blues players to know that despite what you may see hear or read, Johnson is not the center of that universe.

Delta Blues Revisited

Charlie Patton in 1929 with “Spoonful of Blues”

I did two posts in 2018 on the Delta Blues and since then I have mentioned a number of the names to come from the area. Not long ago I did several posts on regional Blues such as Texas, Piedmont and West Coast. There are so many important names to come from the Delta I decided to dedicate some more individual posts. This will be an introduction to those unfamiliar with the region and a bit of history.

It cannot be overstated how important the artists that came from this area are to Popular Music today. These Singers and Songwriters were integral in the development of so many genre. The music from the area was not identifiable as one single entity. There was a strong element of Folk Music and even some Country here. Apart from the Blues genre itself, R&B, Rap, Hip Hop, Rock and Roll, Jazz and yes even (as mentioned) good ole’ Country Music owes much to this region.

Where to start on this topic is difficult, but it seems to me the geography is perhaps best. What we now know as the Delta Blues came from (not surprisingly) the Mississippi Delta. This is a region of the United States that stretches from north to south between Memphis, Tennessee, and Vicksburg, Mississippi, and from east to west between the Yazoo River and the Mississippi River. The river being the blood that feeds the land which at one time was not only the heart of slave country but the fertile soil, the farms, plantations and agriculture that brought them there to begin with.

The Delta Blues Trail

Born of hardship, the life of a slave, subject to discrimination, indentured servitude, sharecropping, and mostly just being very poor the Delta Blues has travelled a long long way in more ways than one. First, the survival of the Blues Singer was dependent on getting gigs, and for that one had to travel from town to town. This was the life of the itinerant musician.

The second aspect of the the ‘travel’ came en masse in the form of the Great Migration, identified as beginning around 1910 and lasting through to nearly 1970. Blacks from the south (not just the Delta) travelled north by the millions for higher paying jobs in the industrialized northern United States, but also the West and Midwest. In this group of weary travelers were musicians from the Delta region and they had guitars on their backs, harmonicas in their pockets and a unique story to tell. Landing in Philadelphia, Chicago, Detroit and New York City in particular they took up jobs in foundries, factories and slaughterhouses.

As hard as the work was and as long as the hours were, many still found time for music and thankfully some of this music got to be recorded so we can still enjoy it today. In terms of how this music was captured there were what is referred to as “Field Recordings” made by Musicologists, Folklorists and many from the Record industry. But somewhat ironically in the early days there were no recording studios in the Delta where the music originated, and the first records in the genre came from Chicago. Possibly the first was by Freddie Spruell in 1926.

As to the first actual “Blues” song recorded, that is a very long story. Short version is that it was written by W.C. Handy (p.1912), who sold it to Theron Bennett, eventually we got “Memphis Blues” by the Victor Military Band, July 15, 1914. It was a Brass band put together by the Victor Talking Machine Company that put out recordings up to 1920. All this and more is a topic for an upcoming post I am still researching titled The Blues.

Freddie Spruell in 1926 with “Muddy Water Blues”

From my research on the Delta there are three key names that keep coming up and much has been written about them. Charlie Patton, Robert Johnson and Son House are the names I will use as a baseline. I will follow with individual posts on them and more.

This topic is not of a deep interest to everyone. Although I plan on an ongoing series I shall intercede with posts on other songs and topics as well.

Thanks for reading and a warm welcome to my new subscribers!

Follow this link to Music Mondays by Leon and travel back to 1986!

Delbert McClinton

“B Movie Boxcar Blues”
“B Movie Boxcar Blues” live cover by The Blues Brothers

I’ve have been thinking about Delbert lately and when Keith posted The Blues Brothers as his favorite soundtrack on Turntable Talk, well that sealed the deal. Myself and others have been talking about some of the great Texas Singer/Songwriters of late, with a focus on the lineage of the Country Folk singers like Guy Clark, Townes Van Zandt and many others. While there are other genre to follow we find that Delbert McClinton’s roots are more closely related to the Blues lineage.

Delbert McClinton was born November 4, 1940 in Lubbock, Texas. If that town (of about 32,000 people at that time) sounds familiar, it’s probably because you know Buddy Holly was born there in 1936, but also Mac Davis in 1942 and Natalie Maines in 1972. Not to mention the many who grew up there, like members of The Crickets. It seems to be “something in the water” as the saying goes.

Just a bit more about Delbert and then on to a bit of music. His family would move to Fort Worth when he was 11. As a young teen he was in a band that would back some of the great names in Blues such Jimmy Reed, Howlin’ Wolf and Lightnin’ Hopkins. Another name was one of the greatest Blues Harmonica players ever, Sonny Boy Williamson II. This might explain why some of that incredible harmonica playing is a part of what makes McClinton so amazing. As you can see and hear in the above clip.

I am probably not alone in the manner in which I found his music. That was courtesy of the legend that is Emmylou Harris. She was the first to cover his song “Two More Bottles of Wine” in 1978 and take it to #1 on both the US and Canadian Country charts.

“Two More Bottles of Wine” by Emmylou Harris (1978)

He won his first Grammy in 1992 (with Bonnie Raitt) and his fourth in 2020. With 30 studio albums there’s goldmine of great music to find. He is a singer/songwriter, with 47 of his original songs covered into hundreds of versions. As a multi instrumentalist he was the harmonica player on Bruce Channel’s “Hey! Baby” from 1962 when he was just 22 years old. He would give some instruction to John Lennon on playing the instrument when he was on tour with Channel in the UK. This was one of Max’s Picks from 1962.

Like many of his ilk the songs don’t often appear on the pop charts but he’s landed a few, but mostly on the Country charts, the highest being “Tell Me About It” when he accompanied Tanya Tucker on her #4 hit song. He has had a couple #1 selling Blues Albums and continues to influence and perform.

“You Were Never Mine” (1997) written by Delbert McClinton, Gary Nicholson and Benmont Tench
“You Were Never Mine” by Etta Britt (2014)

Perhaps his most recognizable tune is a cover of a Jerry Lynn Williams song “Giving It Up for Your Love” from 1980 that peaked at #8 on the Hot 100.

Jerry Lynn Williams (1979)

When we really enjoy an artist it’s tough to pick your favorites but I really like what he did with a cover of the Bonnie Tyler song “Sending Me Angels” (1992) also written by Jerry Lynn Williams with Frankie Miller.

“Sending Me Angels” by Delbert McClinton (1997)

Never too late to go back to Music Mondays by Leon.

DUTC#54 January 28, 2024

Feature Songs: “Pick a Bale of Cotton” / “The Midnight Special” This final January DUTC for 2024 was inspired by my friend Randy Dafoe’s post (Dec.9,…

DUTC#54 January 28, 2024

I am reposting this, not because my friend North provides a very nice link to my blog. Although writing about Ry Cooder and Taj Mahal might be reason enough we both talked about Big Bill Broonzy today. No we did not compare notes and we’re both equally surprised. We all are busy and I myself follow several great blogs but I never miss reading this one.